Introduction
Being named in a mortgage fraud investigation does not automatically mean you committed fraud.
If you joined a property investment scheme believing it was legitimate, the prosecution must establish your personal involvement and the dishonesty required for the offence charged, rather than relying solely on applications submitted in your name.
However, trusting the organisers does not automatically protect you from prosecution.
What matters is what you knew, what you agreed to and whether you understood that false information was being submitted to lenders.
If police have already interviewed you, preserve your investment documents, obtain legal advice before giving another account and check whether any lenders are taking action against your properties.
What Should I Do Immediately After a Police Interview About Mortgage Fraud?
After a police interview concerning a buy-to-let mortgage fraud investigation, your first step is to instruct a specialist fraud solicitor.
Do not contact police again, do not reach out to scheme organisers, and do not deal with any property connected to the investigation without legal guidance.
Every document you received from the scheme is potentially exculpatory evidence.
Seminar materials, projected rental figures, correspondence, sign-up packs, draft applications, emails and messages may all help establish what you were told and what you understood at the time.
That material must be preserved now, before anything is lost.
Do not delete anything from your phone, email accounts or cloud storage.
If the scheme gave you paper documents, keep them in a safe place. If records are digital, do not overwrite or move files. Courts and prosecutors are entitled to examine the full picture of what documents existed and when.
You should also check whether any lender has issued formal correspondence about arrears, enforcement or the validity of your mortgage.
Lender enforcement and criminal proceedings run on separate tracks and have separate deadlines. The section below on properties explains this in more detail.
Can I Be Prosecuted Alongside the Scheme Organisers in a Mortgage Fraud Case?
Investors can be prosecuted alongside brokers or scheme organisers where the evidence supports their involvement in fraud.
However, joining a scheme or signing documents prepared by someone else does not automatically mean you were part of a dishonest arrangement.
Where the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) makes a charging decision, it generally applies the Full Code Test.
The first stage considers whether there is sufficient evidence for a realistic prospect of conviction. The second considers whether prosecution is in the public interest.
Prosecutors must assess the evidence against you personally, including any explanation or defence supported by the available records.
For example, if the organisers supplied income figures, prepared applications and assured you that everything was legitimate, those communications may be relevant to what you knew.
However, if investigators find messages showing that you agreed to inflate your income or conceal existing debts, the evidence may support a different conclusion.
A solicitor can assess the allegations and, where appropriate, make representations before a charging decision is taken.
How Do Investigators Determine Whether I Was Misled or Knowingly Participated in Mortgage Fraud?
Investigators will examine what you knew and believed when the mortgage applications were prepared and submitted.
Under the Fraud Act 2006, fraud by false representation requires proof that a person dishonestly made a false or misleading representation, knowing that it was or might be untrue or misleading, with the intention of making a gain or causing loss or a risk of loss.
Dishonesty is assessed by considering what you actually knew or believed about the facts and whether your conduct was dishonest by ordinary standards.
For example, you may have believed the organisers were using legitimate rental projections or financial information when arranging the mortgages.
If that belief was genuine, it may be relevant to whether the prosecution can establish that you knowingly made a false representation.
However, investigators may also consider whether you saw inaccurate figures, questioned them or agreed to use them despite knowing they were misleading.
If the allegation involves conspiracy to defraud, the prosecution must establish that you were party to a dishonest agreement. Merely associating with people who committed fraud is not enough.
Your emails, investment paperwork and communications with the organisers may help establish what you understood at each stage.

What if I Signed a Mortgage Application the Organisers Prepared?
A signature on an application is evidence, but it is not the end of the legal inquiry in a buy-to-let mortgage fraud investigation.
The central question in cases involving third-party intermediaries is whether the requisite dishonest intent can be established against the client personally.
The Fraud Act 2006 specifies that a representation is made fraudulently if the person making it knows it is or might be untrue or misleading, does not believe it is true, or is reckless as to whether it is true or false.
If you signed forms prepared entirely by the scheme, did not know the figures were false, and had no reason to suspect them, the prosecution must still establish your personal dishonest state of mind.
That is a distinct burden and it cannot be satisfied simply by pointing to the document bearing your signature.
Inadvertent errors on mortgage applications are not typically treated as fraud by the CPS. Conspiracy requires far more than simple involvement or association with others who were acting dishonestly.
In one analogous case, a client who engaged a mortgage broker to manage applications, given the complexity of their financial affairs, was not found to have had dishonest intent even where figures on the applications did not accurately reflect their income.
What you were told at each stage, and your documented reliance on organiser representations, will be examined carefully by both investigators and your defence team.
What Records Can Help Show What I Was Told During a Buy-to-Let Mortgage Scheme?
The timeline of what you were told, and when, is likely to be your most important factual resource in a buy-to-let mortgage fraud investigation.
Documents that existed before you signed anything are particularly valuable because they can establish what representations were made to you before any commitment was made.
Seminar and marketing materials, including brochures, projected return figures and investment pack documents given to you before you signed up, can show the basis on which the scheme was presented to you.
Rental income projections and valuation reports provided by the organisers may show that inflated figures were presented to you as facts rather than estimates.
Email and message chains between you and the organisers are significant. They can show what questions you asked, what assurances were given in response, and the basis on which you chose to proceed.
Draft or completed application documents prepared and sent to you by the organisers, rather than drafted by you, are relevant to whether you had personal knowledge of the figures they contained.
Contracts, terms and conditions and any investor agreements may set out the representations the scheme made formally.
Bank statements and payment records can establish the flow of money, including whether you received any financial benefit beyond the marketed returns.
Conveyancing correspondence and solicitors’ files from the original property transactions may contain valuations, rental assessments and solicitor advice that corroborate what you understood at the time.
Gather this material now, store it securely and do not alter it. Investigators and your defence team will examine the same body of records, and a coherent, contemporaneous documentary record is the most effective way to reconstruct what you actually knew and believed.
What Could Happen to My Properties if Lenders Demand Repayment?
A mortgage fraud investigation does not automatically mean you will lose your properties. However, lenders may take separate action if they believe mortgage applications contained false information or the loan terms have been breached.
The options available to a lender depend on the mortgage agreement, the circumstances and the applicable law.
For example, a lender may investigate suspected misrepresentation, demand repayment where contractually entitled or begin possession proceedings.
Do not ignore letters about arrears, repayment demands or proposed enforcement.
The specific pre-action protocol for residential mortgage arrears does not apply to ordinary buy-to-let mortgages. This means you should not assume that every protection or procedure associated with residential mortgage arrears applies to your investment properties.
Where possession proceedings are brought, the court will consider the legal basis of the claim and any available defence.
You may need advice about the mortgage terms, the original application and whether the lender is entitled to take the action proposed.
A separate issue arises if investigators seek a restraint order under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002.
A restraint order can restrict dealings with property and other assets while a criminal investigation or proceedings continue, provided the statutory conditions are met.
This is different from a lender repossessing a property under a mortgage agreement.
The two processes may run at the same time, and each requires careful attention to its own deadlines and restrictions.
Facing Legal Issue?
Speak to one of our Fraud and Financial Crime Defence Specialists for confidential advice on your position and next steps.
Strictly Confidential and No Obligation

Should I Give Police a Further Account During a Mortgage Fraud Investigation?
Whether to provide another statement or attend a further interview should be discussed with your solicitor first.
You may want to explain that the organisers prepared the applications and that you believed the scheme was legitimate.
However, your explanation should be considered alongside the documents already available and any information disclosed by investigators.
If police invite you to a voluntary interview under caution, your answers can be used as evidence even though you have not been arrested.
Your solicitor can seek information about the allegations and advise on the appropriate response.
Depending on the circumstances, this may involve answering questions, providing a prepared statement or exercising your right to silence.
There can be legal consequences if you later rely on a fact that you could reasonably have mentioned during an interview but did not. A court may draw an adverse inference in certain circumstances.
For that reason, remaining silent or giving a prepared statement should not be treated as an automatic solution.
Before another interview, review the application documents, communications and investment timeline with your solicitor.
Make sure you can distinguish what you personally knew from what you were told by the organisers, and avoid guessing about documents or conversations you cannot clearly remember.
What Penalties Could I Face if Convicted of Buy-to-Let Mortgage Fraud?
Fraud under the Fraud Act 2006 carries a maximum sentence of ten years‘ imprisonment in the Crown Court.
Conspiracy to defraud also carries a maximum of ten years.
These are statutory maximums, not the expected sentences for everyone involved in a fraudulent investment scheme.
If you are convicted, the court will consider your culpability and the harm caused.
Relevant factors may include your role in the scheme, the degree of planning, the financial sums involved and whether you knowingly assisted others.
For example, someone who organised a scheme, prepared false applications and recruited investors may be assessed differently from a participant who had a limited role.
However, a limited role does not automatically mean a lower sentence. The court must consider the actual offending and the applicable sentencing guidelines.
The financial loss suffered or risked by lenders may also be relevant, along with any wider impact.
Following conviction, the court may consider confiscation proceedings under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002.
A confiscation order can require a convicted person to pay an amount assessed under the statutory rules relating to the benefit obtained from criminal conduct.
Other orders may be available in appropriate circumstances.
The outcome will depend on what offence, if any, is proved and your individual involvement.
How a Mortgage Fraud Defence Solicitor Can Help With a Buy-to-Let Investigation
A solicitor experienced in mortgage fraud investigations can review what the police allege you did, what the application documents contain and what evidence exists about your knowledge of the scheme.
They can examine the investment materials, emails, financial projections and other records to establish what the organisers told you and whether you had reason to believe the information submitted to lenders was false.
Where the evidence supports your position, a solicitor may make pre-charge representations explaining why the prosecution cannot establish the required dishonesty or involvement in an alleged conspiracy.
They can also represent you during further police interviews and advise on how to respond to requests for information.
If your mortgage lenders are demanding repayment or threatening possession proceedings, separate advice may be needed about the civil consequences.
A solicitor can help coordinate those issues with the criminal investigation, particularly where statements or documents provided in one process may affect the other.
If a restraint order is made or proposed, legal advice can also help establish what assets are affected and whether an application to vary or discharge the order is appropriate.
Ashmans Solicitors represents individuals facing fraud and financial crime investigations, including allegations involving mortgage fraud.
If you joined a property investment scheme believing it was legitimate and are now being questioned about fraudulent mortgage applications, our team can review the allegations and explain your options.
5 Key Takeaways
- Being named in a mortgage fraud investigation does not automatically establish guilt; prosecutors must assess the evidence of your personal involvement.
- Fraud by false representation requires dishonesty, knowledge that a representation was or might be false, and the intention to make a gain or cause loss.
- Signing applications prepared by organisers is relevant evidence, but the circumstances and what you knew when signing remain important.
- Investment brochures, messages, mortgage documents and payment records may help establish what you were told and whether you knowingly participated.
- Mortgage lender enforcement and criminal restraint orders are separate processes, so preserve your records and obtain advice about both where necessary.
Call us on 0333 009 6275. We are available to take your call 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
You can also email us on enquiries@ashmanssolicitors.com or complete our Online Enquiry Form and we’ll be in touch soon.
Get in touch
We’ll respond within 15 minutes during office hours
Search our legal articles
Free expert guidance on criminal law, your rights, and what to expect at every stage.
Searching Legal Help Hub articles
Related insights and updates



