Introduction
For most jobs in England and Wales, employers cannot require you to disclose spent criminal convictions, and you are not legally obliged to reveal them.
The Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 gives applicants the legal right to answer a standard conviction question without mentioning any criminal record that has become spent.
Different rules apply to certain professions and roles eligible for Standard or Enhanced Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) checks.
This article explains what employers can legally ask about your criminal record, when you need to disclose a conviction or caution, and what to do if your criminal history affects a job application.
What Employers Can Legally Ask About Your Criminal Record
For most jobs, the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 restricts what an employer can ask about criminal records and what an applicant is obliged to answer.
Where a role is not exempt from the Act, an employer is not permitted to ask about spent convictions, and an applicant who does not mention them is not being dishonest.
For unspent criminal records, the position is different. If an employer asks directly, the applicant must answer honestly.
An unspent conviction is one where the rehabilitation period has not yet elapsed, so the conviction remains live for most purposes in law.
An employer can request a basic DBS check for any role, regardless of its nature. A basic DBS check shows only unspent convictions and conditional cautions.
It does not reveal spent convictions, so even where a basic check is carried out, an applicant’s spent criminal record remains protected for non-exempt roles.
When You Need to Disclose a Conviction or Caution
Whether you must disclose your criminal record depends on two things: whether the conviction or caution is spent, and whether the role you are applying for is exempt from the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974.
For unspent convictions and unspent cautions, you must answer honestly if the employer asks. Conditional cautions also appear on a basic DBS check until they become spent.
For spent convictions, the Act generally allows you to answer questions about your criminal history without mentioning them when applying for a non-exempt role.
An employer cannot lawfully refuse you the job or dismiss you simply because you did not disclose a conviction that the law protects.
Certain exempt roles have different disclosure rules. These are explained below.
How rehabilitation periods work
Rehabilitation periods determine when a conviction or caution becomes spent. Changes introduced on 28 October 2023 shortened several of these periods, meaning some convictions now become spent sooner.
Under the current rules, an adult community order generally becomes spent when the order ends.
An adult custodial sentence of one year or less becomes spent one year after the sentence, including any licence period, has ended. For a sentence of more than one year and up to four years, the rehabilitation period is four years after completion.
Different periods apply to cautions, other sentences and people convicted before turning 18.
Some convictions for serious violent, sexual or terrorism offences resulting in custodial sentences of more than four years never become spent. Other custodial sentences exceeding four years may become spent after the applicable rehabilitation period.
It is therefore important to check the sentence received, rather than assuming that every conviction becomes spent after the same number of years.
Spent and Filtered Criminal Records: Why the Difference Matters
Spent status and filtering are two separate processes. Both affect what may appear on a DBS certificate, but they apply differently depending on the level of check.
Even where a role is exempt from the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974, not every spent conviction will necessarily appear on a Standard or Enhanced DBS certificate.
Filtering rules automatically protect certain older or minor convictions and cautions from routine disclosure. Applicants are generally not required to reveal protected records, even when applying for an exempt role eligible for a higher-level DBS check.
The rules consider the type of offence, the age of the person when convicted or cautioned and the time that has passed.
For example, an adult conviction for a non-specified offence that did not result in a custodial sentence may be filtered after 11 years, provided it meets the other requirements.
A spent conviction that does not qualify for filtering may still appear on a Standard or Enhanced certificate and can generally be considered for an eligible role.
What filtering does not cover
Certain serious offences are never filtered from automatic criminal record disclosure. These are known as specified offences and include many violent, sexual and safeguarding-related offences.
Convictions resulting in custodial sentences, including suspended sentences, are also automatically disclosed on Standard and Enhanced DBS checks, regardless of how long ago they occurred.
Filtering does not erase an offence from police records. It prevents protected information from being routinely disclosed on the certificate.
In some circumstances, an Enhanced DBS check may still contain information relating to a protected offence if the police consider it relevant to the role and disclosure meets the applicable legal safeguards.

How the Rules Change for Different Roles
Standard and enhanced DBS checks into criminal records are not available for every job. They can only be carried out where the specific role, or the regulated activities within it, falls within the scope of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 Exceptions Order 1975 or the Police Act 1997 (Criminal Records) Regulations.
Eligibility is assessed by reference to what the person actually does, not what their job title says.
Two employees in the same organisation with the same job title may have different DBS eligibility if their day-to-day duties differ.
An employer cannot request a standard or enhanced DBS check simply because they would like one; the role must qualify.
Where a role is exempt, the employer may ask about spent criminal records that appear on the DBS certificate and have not been filtered.
For enhanced checks, locally held police intelligence may also be included if the relevant chief officer considers it relevant to the duties of the role, even where that information did not result in a conviction.
An enhanced check with a barred list check is available only for roles involving regulated activity with children or adults at risk.
This is the highest level of criminal record check and carries additional safeguarding information.
Examples of roles and check levels
These examples are illustrative only. Actual eligibility must be confirmed against the specific post and its duties.
- A teacher working directly with children is likely to require an enhanced DBS check including a check of the children’s barred list, because the role involves regulated activity.
- An NHS administrator who does not have unsupervised access to patients may require only a standard check, depending on their precise duties.
- A retail worker would typically face no DBS requirement beyond a basic criminal record check if one is requested at all, because retail work does not ordinarily fall within the Exceptions Order.
What if a Job Application Asks for Your Entire Criminal Record?
Some application forms ask applicants to list all previous convictions and cautions without explaining whether spent records should be included.
A broadly worded question does not override the protections in the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974.
For a non-exempt role, you can answer without disclosing spent convictions, regardless of whether the employer has asked about your entire criminal history.
For an exempt role, the employer may lawfully ask about relevant spent convictions and cautions that are not protected by filtering.
You generally do not need to disclose filtered records, even for an exempt position. A small number of specially designated roles have different disclosure arrangements, so the particular eligibility rules should be checked.
Before answering, establish whether the job is exempt and what information the employer is legally entitled to request.
A practical example
An applicant for a warehouse supervisor role sees a question on the form asking them to list all past convictions and cautions. The role does not require a standard or enhanced DBS check.
The applicant has one spent conviction on their criminal record and one unspent conviction. The applicant is entitled to disclose only the unspent conviction.
They are not deceiving the employer by doing so, because the law treats the question as not covering the spent criminal record.
An applicant for a teaching assistant role sees the same broadly worded question. The role involves regulated activity with children, so it is an exempt position.
The applicant must disclose all unspent convictions and all spent criminal records that have not been filtered. A filtered spent conviction still does not need to be disclosed, even for this role.
Facing Legal Issue?
Speak to one of our Fraud and Financial Crime Defence Specialists for confidential advice on your position and next steps.
Strictly Confidential and No Obligation

Can an Employer Withdraw a Job Offer Because of Your Criminal Record?
An employer withdrawing a job offer because of an unspent conviction is not automatically acting unlawfully. However, the employer should consider whether the offence is relevant to the duties of the role and assess the circumstances fairly.
Withdrawing an offer solely because of a spent conviction for a non-exempt role would generally breach the protections provided by the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974.
The same protections generally prevent employers from rejecting applicants because of convictions or cautions that are protected by filtering.
For exempt roles, employers may consider relevant spent convictions that are not protected. However, an individual assessment is expected, rather than automatically excluding anyone with a criminal record.
For example, the nature of the offence, when it occurred and its relevance to the position may all be considered.
Employers must also comply with data protection law when handling criminal record information. Under UK GDPR, criminal offence data receives additional protection through Article 10 and the Data Protection Act 2018.
It is not technically classified as special category data, but its processing is subject to specific restrictions.
Where criminal record information has been collected or used unlawfully, a complaint to the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) may be appropriate.
What to check if your offer is withdrawn
If an employer withdraws an offer after learning about your criminal record, consider whether the conviction was spent and whether the role was exempt from the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974.
You should also check whether the information should have been filtered and whether the employer was legally entitled to consider it.
For an unspent or lawfully disclosable conviction, the employer’s reasons for withdrawing the offer may be relevant.
A blanket exclusion policy, particularly where no consideration is given to the offence or duties, may raise concerns.
If you believe your criminal record information was handled unlawfully, you may also need advice about data protection rights and the options available to challenge the decision.
When to Get Advice About Criminal Record Disclosure
Not every situation requires a solicitor, but there are circumstances where legal advice may help.
For example, you may need advice if an employer asks about spent convictions for a non-exempt role or withdraws an offer after discovering a record you were not legally required to disclose.
A solicitor can also help if you are unsure whether a role qualifies for a Standard or Enhanced DBS check or whether your conviction meets the filtering criteria.
If your DBS certificate includes information you believe is inaccurate or should not have been disclosed, you can use the DBS disputes process. Legal advice may help establish whether there are grounds to challenge it.
Where an employer has handled criminal record information unlawfully, an ICO complaint may be available.
Depending on the circumstances, employment law remedies may also apply if you have been dismissed or subjected to disciplinary action because of a spent conviction.
How a Solicitor Can Help
Ashmans advises clients about criminal record disclosure, DBS checks and the possible employment consequences of convictions and cautions.
A solicitor can review whether an employer was entitled to ask about particular convictions, assess whether a job offer was lawfully withdrawn and explain the options available if criminal record information has been handled incorrectly.
If you are preparing a job application and are unsure what to disclose, advice beforehand may help you avoid unnecessary disclosure or inaccurate answers.
Where a dispute has already arisen, a solicitor can examine the circumstances and advise whether a formal challenge or complaint is appropriate.
Our criminal law solicitors can advise on criminal record disclosure and its implications for employment and professional standing.
Speak to our team for advice about your position and next steps.
5 Key Takeaways
- For most jobs in England and Wales, you are not legally required to disclose spent convictions under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974.
- Standard and Enhanced DBS checks are available only for eligible roles, with eligibility determined by the duties involved.
- Filtering protects certain older convictions and cautions from routine disclosure, even where a higher-level DBS check is permitted.
- Employers generally cannot reject applicants because of spent convictions for non-exempt roles or records protected by filtering.
- Criminal offence data has additional legal protections, and employers must have a lawful basis and meet specific conditions when handling it.
Frequently Asked Questions
A spent conviction is one where the rehabilitation period has passed, so you generally do not need to disclose it for most jobs.
An employer can request a Basic DBS check for any role. Standard and Enhanced checks are limited to eligible positions, with eligibility determined by the actual duties rather than the job title.
Not for most jobs. You generally do not have to disclose spent convictions for non-exempt roles, even if the form asks about all offences. Different rules apply to exempt positions, but protected records usually remain excluded.
Filtering automatically excludes certain protected convictions and cautions from Standard and Enhanced DBS certificates. It depends on the offence, your age and how much time has passed.
You can raise a dispute with the DBS if the certificate contains incorrect information or a record that should have been filtered. Explain the error and provide supporting evidence. Standard and Enhanced certificate disputes should normally be raised within three months.
It depends on whether the conviction is spent and whether the role is exempt. Employers generally cannot refuse employment because of a protected spent conviction, but they may consider relevant records that they are legally entitled to know about.
The October 2023 reforms shortened rehabilitation periods for several sentences. Some convictions may now become spent sooner, including certain community orders and custodial sentences.
Call us on 0333 009 6275. We are available to take your call 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
You can also email us on enquiries@ashmanssolicitors.com or complete our Online Enquiry Form and we’ll be in touch soon.
Get in touch
We’ll respond within 15 minutes during office hours
Search our legal articles
Free expert guidance on criminal law, your rights, and what to expect at every stage.
Searching Legal Help Hub articles
Related insights and updates



