Introduction
If the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has contacted you, your rights depend on whether you are under investigation, acting as a witness or responding on behalf of a regulated firm. Receiving an FCA letter does not automatically mean you are suspected of a criminal offence, and an investigation may end without formal action.
The FCA investigates suspected regulatory breaches and financial crime under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA). The powers it can use, and what you must do in response, depend on the type of investigation and your involvement.
This guide explains your FCA investigation rights in England and Wales, including what happens when investigators are appointed, how to respond to information requests, your rights during interviews and the possible outcomes.
What Does an FCA Investigation Mean?
Understanding what type of regulatory process you are facing matters before deciding how to respond.
The FCA’s engagement with firms and individuals falls broadly into two categories: ongoing supervision and formal enforcement.
These processes carry different legal consequences and demand different responses.
Supervision and Enforcement: Different Processes, Different Consequences
Supervision is the FCA’s ongoing oversight of authorised firms. It does not, in law, constitute a formal investigation.
When the regulator concludes that potential misconduct warrants more intensive scrutiny, it opens what it describes as an Enforcement Operation and appoints investigators under FSMA 2000.
In practice, supervisory engagement can still carry high costs and disruption, even where no formal investigation has begun.
Requirements imposed at the supervisory stage can be binding and may carry reputational consequences. Knowing which process you are in shapes the appropriate response from the outset.
The Notice of Appointment of Investigators
When the FCA formally appoints investigators, you or your firm may receive a Notice of Appointment of Investigators and a Memorandum of Appointment. These documents explain who has been appointed, the legal powers being used and the matters under investigation.
However, the FCA does not have to notify everyone immediately in every investigation. Whether notice is required depends on the statutory powers involved and the circumstances.
If you receive these documents, read them carefully and seek legal advice. They help establish the scope of the investigation, what the FCA may require and your rights during the process.
Section 167 and Section 168 FSMA: Why the Power Used Matters
Section 167 FSMA authorises a general investigation into the nature, conduct or state of a business or the ownership or control of an authorised person, without a specific identified breach.
If no particular contravention has been identified but the FCA considers a general investigation warranted, investigators will be appointed under this section.
Section 168 FSMA applies where a specific rule breach or fitness and propriety concern has been identified.
The section under which investigators are appointed matters for two reasons.
- First, it determines which investigatory powers the FCA may use.
- Second, it determines whether the subject of the investigation must be notified at the outset.
Dual-Track Investigations
The FCA may investigate suspected conduct for both regulatory breaches and possible criminal offences. This is known as a dual-track investigation.
It allows the regulator to consider whether the evidence supports civil or regulatory enforcement, criminal prosecution or another response.
Being involved in a dual-track investigation does not mean you will face criminal charges. It means criminal proceedings remain a possibility while the FCA examines the evidence.
The distinction matters because different interview procedures and legal protections apply depending on how the FCA is investigating the conduct.
Understanding Your Status and the Scope of the Investigation
Not every person or firm that receives FCA correspondence is under investigation.
Third parties, witnesses and firms subject to general supervisory review all receive FCA letters. Identifying your status accurately at the outset determines which rights and obligations apply and whether the interests of an individual and their employer are aligned.
The Significance of Your Status
The type of interview or request you receive is a key indicator of your position.
The FCA uses four main types of interviews: voluntary interviews, compelled interviews under statutory powers, interviews under caution and interviews under arrest.
Each signals a materially different status and carries different obligations and protections under your FCA investigation rights.
Where individual and firm interests may diverge, independent legal representation becomes particularly important.
A solicitor acting for the firm cannot give advice that is solely in your personal interest if that conflicts with the firm’s position.
When the FCA May Not Notify You
The FCA does not always have to inform someone as soon as investigators are appointed. In certain circumstances, notice is not legally required, or disclosure may be delayed because it could prejudice the investigation.
For example, early notification could create concerns about relevant documents being destroyed or evidence being affected.
You could therefore be under investigation before receiving formal correspondence. An unexpected request should not be taken to mean that the FCA has only recently started examining the matter.
Steps to Take When Checking Your Status
Read all documentation received, including any notice of appointment, memorandum of appointment and any covering letter, carefully and in full.
Identify the statutory basis cited, the named investigators, the entities and time periods in scope and any deadlines stated on the face of the document.
Do not assume that a request addressed to your firm automatically makes you personally a subject. Equally, do not assume that a witness invitation carries no personal risk.
Your status can change as an investigation develops, and what you say or produce at an early stage may become relevant later. Instruct a solicitor before responding to any formal request.

Responding to Information and Document Requests
Once you have identified the legal basis and scope of the contact, the next step is to understand what you are required to do, what you may decline and how to respond without creating further risk to your position.
Voluntary Requests and Compulsory Requirements
The FCA may initially request documents or information informally or through a supervisory letter.
These requests may feel obligatory but do not always carry the same legal consequences as a formal compulsory requirement.
Identifying which type of request you have received determines what you must do and what you may legitimately decline or negotiate.
The FCA can compel authorised persons and certain connected parties to provide specified information or documents. Formal compulsory requirements carry legal deadlines and statutory consequences for non-compliance.
If you are unsure whether a request is voluntary or compulsory, treat it as serious and take legal advice promptly.
What You Must Provide and What Is Protected
You must generally comply with a lawful compulsory requirement. Failing to do so without a reasonable excuse can result in court proceedings for contempt and may also lead to regulatory consequences.
Deliberately concealing, destroying or falsifying relevant documents, or knowingly providing false or misleading material, can amount to a separate criminal offence.
However, certain documents are protected by legal professional privilege. This generally includes confidential communications with your solicitor made for the purpose of obtaining legal advice.
Commercial sensitivity, confidentiality agreements and data protection obligations do not automatically justify withholding documents required by law.
If you believe material is privileged or otherwise protected, ask your solicitor to review it before anything is disclosed.
Practical Steps When Responding
Note the deadline stated in the requirement and do not allow it to pass without engaging, even if you are contesting the scope.
Review all documents before production and flag anything that may be privileged to your solicitor before disclosure takes place. Keep a full record of everything produced, in what form and to whom.
If the scope of a requirement appears disproportionate or legally questionable, your solicitor can engage with the FCA to clarify or challenge it.
Responding late or incompletely while a challenge is under way still carries risk. Advance engagement is more effective than attempting to correct a deficient response after the deadline has passed.
Compelled Interviews and Interviews Under Caution
The type of interview you are required or invited to attend is one of the most significant indicators of your status and the direction of the investigation.
Understanding your FCA investigation rights at interview, whether compelled or under caution, is essential before you attend.
Compelled Interviews Under Statutory Powers
The FCA can use statutory powers under FSMA to require certain individuals to attend an interview and answer questions relevant to an investigation.
Where a valid compulsory requirement applies, attendance and responses are legally required. Refusing without a reasonable excuse may lead to contempt proceedings.
Compelled interviews can be used to gather information from people connected with a regulated firm, witnesses and others within the scope of the relevant powers.
Receiving such a notice does not necessarily mean you are suspected of a criminal offence.
SMA and the Use of Compelled Answers
Answers given under compulsory investigatory powers receive important protection against being used against the person who provided them in criminal proceedings.
This reflects the principle that someone required by law to answer questions should not ordinarily have those answers used to establish their own criminal liability.
However, the protection has limits. Certain proceedings and offences are exceptions, and answers may become admissible in specified circumstances.
It is therefore important to understand exactly what the FCA is requiring you to answer and how those answers could be used. Compulsory questioning does not provide blanket immunity from prosecution.
Interviews Under Caution
An interview under caution may take place where the FCA suspects someone of a criminal offence. These interviews follow the relevant safeguards under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.
Unlike a compelled interview, a suspect interviewed voluntarily under caution does not have to answer questions.
However, remaining silent can have consequences in some criminal proceedings, particularly where a person later relies on facts they could reasonably have mentioned during questioning.
Whether to answer questions, remain silent or provide a prepared statement should be discussed with a solicitor before the interview.
Your Right to a Solicitor at Interview
You can have legal representation during an FCA interview, whether it is compulsory or conducted under caution.
The FCA normally permits interviewees to be accompanied by their own legal adviser, although it may object to a particular adviser where their involvement could prejudice the investigation, including because of a conflict of interest.
For an interview under caution, obtaining independent advice before questioning is especially important.
Legal representation is also valuable during a compelled interview. Your solicitor can explain the powers being used, prepare you for the likely questions and raise procedural concerns where appropriate.
If your interests differ from those of your employer, consider instructing a solicitor who does not also represent the firm.
Legal Advice, Confidentiality and Privilege
Legal professional privilege can protect certain communications and documents during an FCA investigation. It is different from ordinary confidentiality, and misunderstanding that distinction can lead to material being disclosed unnecessarily.
Legal Professional Privilege
Legal professional privilege generally protects confidential communications between clients and qualified legal advisers made for the purpose of obtaining legal advice.
It can also protect certain communications and documents created for the dominant purpose of litigation that is reasonably in prospect.
The FCA cannot generally compel disclosure of legally privileged material.
Advice from an in-house solicitor may qualify for privilege where the legal requirements are met. However, communications with compliance staff or other employees do not become privileged simply because they concern legal issues or are labelled confidential.
Where the FCA challenges a claim of privilege, the issue should be addressed through the appropriate procedure before disclosure.
Confidentiality Is Not Privilege
A document may contain commercially sensitive information without being legally privileged.
Non-disclosure agreements, business confidentiality and data protection obligations do not, on their own, prevent the FCA from obtaining information under its statutory powers.
These concerns may justify discussing the scope or handling of material with investigators, but they are not necessarily grounds for refusing production.
Before releasing documents, ask your solicitor to distinguish privileged communications from information that is merely confidential. Accidental disclosure of privileged material can create difficult questions about whether protection has been waived.
Tipping Off and Confidentiality of the Investigation
Some investigations involve restrictions on what you may disclose to others. For example, specific tipping-off offences can arise in connection with money laundering disclosures and investigations under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002.
These restrictions do not apply automatically to every FCA investigation. Their application depends on the circumstances and the relevant legal provisions.
The FCA may also request confidentiality or impose restrictions where it has the legal power to do so.
Before discussing an investigation with colleagues, business contacts or the media, check whether any restrictions apply and what information you are permitted to share.
Facing Legal Issue?
Speak to one of our Business Crime and Regulatory Defence Specialists for confidential advice on your position and next steps.
Strictly Confidential and No Obligation

Possible Outcomes, Regulatory Sanctions and Criminal Sentencing
An FCA investigation can lead to a range of outcomes, from no further action through regulatory sanctions to criminal prosecution.
The applicable outcome depends on the nature of the conduct, the section of FSMA or other legislation engaged, the evidence gathered and decisions made by the FCA and, ultimately, a court.
No Further Action
A significant proportion of FCA investigations close without formal action.
The FCA may conclude that the evidence does not support a finding of misconduct, that action would not be in the public interest or that the matter is better addressed through supervisory means.
Receiving a closure letter does not necessarily mean the matter cannot be revisited if new evidence emerges.
Regulatory Sanctions and Civil Outcomes
Where regulatory misconduct is established, the FCA may impose financial penalties or issue a public censure.
It can also vary or cancel a firm’s authorisation, restrict certain activities or prohibit individuals from performing regulated functions. For someone working in financial services, a prohibition order may have serious career consequences.
Many contested enforcement decisions involve a formal notice procedure. The FCA may issue a Warning Notice explaining its proposed action and allow the recipient to make representations.
If it maintains its decision, it may issue a Decision Notice. Depending on the action and relevant procedure, the recipient may be able to refer the decision to the Upper Tribunal.
The precise decision-making process depends on the powers being exercised and the type of action proposed.
Asset Freezing and Interim Protective Measures
During an investigation, the FCA may apply to court for an asset freezing order to prevent funds or assets being dissipated before an outcome is determined.
Asset freezing orders can be made on a without-notice basis in urgent cases and can extend to assets held by third parties in some circumstances.
Such orders have immediate practical consequences for a business or individual’s ability to operate and must be responded to promptly with specialist advice.
The FCA also has powers to apply for restitution orders requiring firms or individuals to pay sums to consumers who have suffered loss as a result of regulatory contraventions.
Criminal Prosecution and Sentencing
Where the FCA decides to pursue a criminal route, it may prosecute offences under FSMA 2000, the Fraud Act 2006, the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 and other legislation.
Relevant FSMA offences include carrying on regulated activities without authorisation and making misleading statements under section 89 of the Financial Services Act 2012.
Market abuse prosecuted as a criminal offence under FSMA can carry a maximum sentence of seven years’ imprisonment on conviction on indictment.
Fraud Act offences carry a maximum of ten years’ imprisonment on conviction on indictment.
Sentences imposed in practice depend on the specific conduct, any aggravating or mitigating factors, the defendant’s role and whether a guilty plea was entered.
Criminal proceedings before the Crown Court carry significant consequences beyond sentence, including a criminal record, confiscation proceedings under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 and ancillary orders.
Specialist criminal defence representation is essential in this context.
Early Engagement and Settlement
The FCA allows some regulatory enforcement cases to be resolved through settlement.
Under its early settlement scheme, an eligible firm or individual may receive a reduction of up to 30% in the relevant financial penalty if an agreement is reached during the applicable early stage.
Settlement can reduce the time and expense of contested proceedings, but it also involves agreeing to specified terms, which may include facts, breaches and sanctions.
Whether settlement is appropriate depends on the evidence, the proposed outcome and any wider consequences, particularly if criminal proceedings are also possible.
How a Solicitor Can Support Your FCA Investigation Rights
If the FCA has contacted you or your firm, a solicitor experienced in regulatory investigations can help establish your position and explain what happens next.
They can review the FCA’s correspondence, identify the powers being used and advise on which requests are legally binding. They can also check documents for privilege, discuss the scope of information requirements with investigators and help prepare responses.
If you are asked to attend an interview, your solicitor can explain your rights, prepare you for questioning and attend with you where permitted.
Independent representation is particularly important where your interests differ from those of your employer. If an asset freezing order has been made or threatened, specialist advice can also help you understand its restrictions and any options for challenging or varying it.
Our business crime and regulatory team advises individuals and firms facing FCA investigations, including those involving suspected financial misconduct, compulsory interviews and asset freezing orders.
Speak to a Solicitor at Ashmans Solicitors for advice about your FCA investigation rights and the steps available to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Not necessarily. The FCA contacts people for routine supervision, information requests and witness enquiries, as well as formal investigations. Check the purpose of the letter and seek legal advice if your status is unclear.
It depends on the interview. You must generally answer questions under a valid compulsory requirement, but you can decline to answer questions in a voluntary interview under caution. Your solicitor can explain which rules apply.
Compelled answers are generally protected against being used against you in criminal proceedings, subject to specific exceptions. Voluntary answers do not carry the same protection and may be used as evidence.
Yes. The FCA normally allows you to have your own legal adviser present, although it can object to a particular adviser where there is a risk of prejudice to the investigation. Independent advice is especially important if you are interviewed under caution.
A regulatory penalty is imposed through the FCA’s enforcement powers and may involve a fine, public censure or restrictions on regulated activities. A criminal conviction follows court proceedings and can result in imprisonment, fines and a criminal record.
An asset freezing order restricts how you can deal with specified money or property. It may affect access to personal funds or business assets, although exceptions or variations may be available. Seek specialist advice promptly if an order is made against you.
The FCA may close the investigation without formal action and notify the person concerned. This does not necessarily prevent further investigation if new evidence emerges, but no enforcement sanction is being pursued through that investigation at that stage.
You may be contacted as a witness, employee or individual subject of the investigation. Your obligations depend on the request and your status. If your interests could conflict with those of your employer, consider obtaining independent legal representation.
Call us on 0333 009 6275. We are available to take your call 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
You can also email us on enquiries@ashmanssolicitors.com or complete our Online Enquiry Form and we’ll be in touch soon.
Get in touch
We’ll respond within 15 minutes during office hours
Search our legal articles
Free expert guidance on criminal law, your rights, and what to expect at every stage.
Searching Legal Help Hub articles
Related insights and updates



