Strategic Advice
Client-Focussed
Proven Record
Strategic Advice
Client-Focussed
Proven Record
Strategic Advice
Client-Focussed
Proven Record

HMRC MTIC Investigation: Am I a Witness or a Suspect, and What Should I Do?

Accountant and officer during an HMRC MTIC investigation
Strategic Advice
Client-Focussed
Proven Record
Strategic Advice
Client-Focussed
Proven Record
Strategic Advice
Client-Focussed
Proven Record

Table of Contents

How Do I Find Out if HMRC Is Treating Me as a Witness or a Suspect?

Ask the question plainly and in writing before agreeing to attend any meeting or provide any further information. 

HMRC is not required to volunteer your status at the outset, and many people first learn they are under criminal investigation only when a search warrant is executed, when they receive a formal request to attend a voluntary interview under caution, or when they are arrested.

Why HMRC May Not Volunteer Your Status

Unlike civil compliance checks, HMRC criminal investigations frequently proceed without notifying the subject that a criminal enquiry has begun. 

HMRC’s Criminal Investigation Policy confirms that it is often the case that a suspect under criminal investigation does not know they are under criminal investigation. 

The first indication may come through a formal enforcement step rather than any warning.

Accountants, bookkeepers and tax advisers who act for businesses in import and export sectors are a recognised focus in MTIC cases. 

HMRC may treat a professional who filed repayment claims for a client later found to be a conduit trader as a potential participant in the fraud network rather than an independent filer of returns. 

The professional’s role, the level of contact with the client, and any visible red flags in the underlying records will all be considered.

How to Ask and What to Look for in the Response

You or your solicitor can ask HMRC to confirm the purpose of the proposed interview and whether you are suspected of an offence.

An invitation to an interview under caution indicates that you are being questioned as a suspect.

A request for a witness statement or an informal meeting may instead indicate that HMRC wants information about your clients.

However, your status can change as the investigation develops.

If the questions begin focusing on your own decisions, knowledge or possible involvement, obtain legal advice before continuing.

What to Do if Your Status Has Already Changed After an Earlier Interview

You may have attended an earlier meeting believing that HMRC only wanted information about your clients.

If investigators subsequently developed grounds to suspect you of an offence, the relevant safeguards should have applied before further questioning about your involvement.

Under PACE Code C, a person must generally be cautioned before being questioned about an offence where there are grounds to suspect their involvement and their answers or silence may be used in evidence.

If that did not happen, your solicitor can review the earlier interview and consider whether any procedural challenge is available.

Preserve the interview invitation, correspondence, notes and any record of the questions asked.

What Is the Difference Between a Witness Interview and an Interview Under Caution?

A witness interview and an interview under caution are fundamentally different in legal standing, procedural rights and evidential consequence. 

Treating them as equivalent is one of the more serious errors an accountant facing an HMRC MTIC investigation can make.

Witness Interview

A witness interview is voluntary. It is not conducted under PACE Code C and responses are not automatically evidence of criminal involvement on your part. 

You may be asked about what you observed, what records you held or what instructions you received from your client. 

The purpose is to gather background information rather than to build a case against you personally.

Your status as a witness can change. If the questioning develops in a way that leads the HMRC officer to suspect your involvement in an offence, the interview should stop and the caution should be administered before it continues. 

If you have any concern that the questions being asked are moving from information-gathering into scrutiny of your own conduct, pause and seek legal advice before continuing.

Interview Under Caution

An interview under caution is a formal part of a criminal investigation.

You will be told that you do not have to answer questions, although failing to mention something you later rely on in court may, in certain circumstances, affect your defence. Anything you say may be used as evidence.

If you attend voluntarily, you are not under arrest and generally have the right to leave, although HMRC may consider arrest if the legal requirements are met.

You can obtain legal advice and have a solicitor present during questioning.

The Three Choices Before an Interview Under Caution

When invited to attend an interview under caution, the decision to be made with legal advice is which of three approaches to take. 

  • First, you may answer HMRC’s questions. 
  • Second, you may provide a prepared written statement covering the relevant facts and decline to answer further questions. 
  • Third, you may give a no-comment interview.

Each approach carries different risks depending on the evidence HMRC already holds, what your working papers show and what instructions you received from your client. 

A prepared written statement is frequently the most effective option where the facts support you, because it places your account on the record before any adverse inference can arise, without exposing you to unpredictable follow-up questions. 

That assessment, however, can only be made properly by a solicitor who has reviewed the available evidence.

Two professionals boxing up files and records for an HMRC MTIC investigation

Can I Be Prosecuted for VAT Returns I Filed Using Client Records?

An accountant can face prosecution for knowingly assisting fraudulent VAT evasion. However, preparing returns from client-supplied information does not automatically establish that you knew the underlying transactions were fraudulent.

The prosecution must prove the requirements of the particular offence charged.

The Criminal Test of the Value Added Tax Act 1994

The Value Added Tax Act 1994 makes it an offence to be knowingly concerned in fraudulent VAT evasion, including steps taken towards another person’s evasion.

This can apply to professionals who knowingly assist fraudulent arrangements. However, recklessness alone is not sufficient to establish the knowledge required for this offence.

Deliberately avoiding information because you suspect fraud may be treated differently from simply failing to identify an irregularity.

For example, knowingly submitting fictitious invoices to support VAT repayment claims could raise criminal liability.

Filing a return based on records you reasonably understood to be genuine is a different situation.

Why Reliance on Client Records Is Not Automatic Protection

Accountants routinely prepare returns using records supplied by clients. HMRC may nevertheless examine whether those records contained warning signs that you recognised or deliberately ignored.

In an MTIC investigation, questions may arise about unusually large repayment claims, repeated transactions involving the same businesses or trading arrangements that appeared commercially unusual.

These circumstances do not automatically establish knowledge of fraud. Your correspondence, working papers and questions raised with clients may help show how you assessed the information before filing.

The Important Distinction From the Civil Kittel Test

HMRC may deny a trader’s input VAT recovery where it establishes that the trader knew or should have known that a transaction was connected to VAT fraud.

This is known as the Kittel principle. It applies in civil VAT disputes and is assessed on the balance of probabilities.

Criminal prosecution requires proof beyond reasonable doubt of the particular offence, including the necessary mental element.

A civil decision denying your client’s VAT claim does not automatically establish that you, as their accountant, committed an offence.

Conspiracy to Defraud and Other Potential Charges

Where investigators believe several people agreed to participate in a dishonest scheme, they may consider conspiracy to defraud. This is separate from the offence of knowingly participating in fraudulent VAT evasion.

For example, knowingly agreeing with clients to submit false claims could support an allegation of conspiracy. However, the prosecution would need to establish the dishonest agreement and your involvement.

The fact that you prepared returns for businesses involved in a fraudulent scheme does not, on its own, prove that you agreed to participate.

Should I Get My Own Solicitor Before Speaking to HMRC Again?

If there is any realistic possibility that HMRC views you as a suspect in an MTIC investigation, or if you are uncertain, independent legal advice before any further contact is a practical necessity. 

This is not a precaution reserved for those who believe they have done something wrong. It is relevant precisely because the question of what you knew and when you knew it is one that an experienced solicitor should assess before you answer it in front of HMRC.

Why Your Interests and Your Clients’ Interests Have Diverged

A solicitor who acts for your client cannot act for you where there is a conflict of interest, and in an HMRC MTIC investigation a conflict is very likely to exist. 

The interests of a client facing prosecution for being a fraudulent trader are not the same as the interests of an accountant who may face scrutiny for knowingly filing returns for that trader. 

Under the Solicitors Regulation Authority’s Code of Conduct, a solicitor must not act for two clients where there is a conflict between those clients’ interests.

If you have previously received legal advice through a firm acting for your client, that firm cannot continue to advise you once your interests diverge. 

Advice received through a shared representative may also be inadvertently shaped by the client’s interests. You need independent representation from a solicitor instructed solely by you.

What Independent Advice Allows You to Do

Advice sought before HMRC contact proceeds allows you to establish your status in writing before committing to any interview. 

It allows you to decide with informed guidance whether to attend voluntarily, provide a prepared statement or decline to attend.

It allows you to review your working papers and correspondence in a legally privileged context, assessing what they show without producing anything prematurely. 

It also allows you to consider your professional body obligations before making any disclosure that could affect your registration.

Your own communications with an independent solicitor for the purpose of obtaining legal advice are protected by legal professional privilege. 

That privilege belongs to you, not to your client, and it cannot be overridden by an HMRC information notice.

Timing Matters

Advice sought before a first interview is more valuable than advice sought after answers have already been given. 

If you attended an earlier interview without independent legal advice, your position is not irretrievable, but the content of that earlier interview needs to be reviewed before any follow-up contact takes place. 

What was said, the framing of the questions and whether the caution was administered at the right point are all relevant to your current position.

How Do I Handle Client Confidentiality When HMRC Requests Records?

Client confidentiality and legal professional privilege are not the same thing. 

Understanding the difference determines what you can withhold, what you are required to produce and what risks you create by producing documents without taking advice first.

As an accountant, you have professional duties to protect client information. However, those duties are different from legal professional privilege.

Legal professional privilege generally protects confidential communications with a lawyer made for the purpose of obtaining legal advice, along with certain material created for litigation.

Ordinary accounting records, working papers and client correspondence do not automatically receive that protection. You should therefore establish whether HMRC has a statutory right to the material before deciding what to disclose.

Formal Powers Versus Informal Requests

HMRC may ask informally for records or use statutory information-gathering powers. Under the Finance Act 2008, HMRC can issue information notices requiring relevant documents or information where the legal conditions are met.

Some notices can be appealed, although appeal rights are restricted for certain documents and circumstances.

A valid notice cannot simply be ignored. Your solicitor can review its scope, identify any available exemptions and advise on the deadline.

What to Do When Records Relate to Both You and Your Client

Some documents may be relevant to your client’s VAT position and to HMRC’s assessment of your own conduct. For example, emails discussing questionable invoices may show what information you received before filing the returns.

Preserve those records and provide them to your solicitor for review. Do not assume that all client documents must be handed over immediately, or that confidentiality alone provides grounds to withhold them.

The correct response depends on whether HMRC’s request is voluntary or compulsory and what legal protections apply.

Anti-Money Laundering Reporting Obligations

Accountants working in the regulated sector may have separate obligations under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002.

If you know or suspect money laundering through information obtained in your professional work, you may be required to make a Suspicious Activity Report, subject to the statutory conditions and any applicable exceptions.

There are also restrictions on disclosures that could prejudice an investigation, including certain forms of tipping off. These obligations must be considered separately from HMRC’s interview request.

Obtain advice before discussing any suspected money laundering report with clients or other parties.

Could the Investigation Affect My Professional Registration?

Yes. Depending on your professional body and the nature of the allegations, an HMRC investigation may raise reporting or disciplinary concerns. These can arise separately from criminal proceedings.

ICAEW Reporting Obligations

ICAEW members and relevant firms have duties to report matters that may indicate disciplinary misconduct. The duty is not necessarily limited to convictions or formal criminal charges.

For example, an allegation that you knowingly submitted false VAT returns may require consideration under ICAEW’s reporting rules. However, being contacted as a witness does not automatically mean you have committed professional misconduct.

Check the applicable requirements and obtain advice about whether a report is necessary.

ICAEW Disciplinary Powers

ICAEW can investigate allegations of professional misconduct and impose disciplinary sanctions where its rules permit. These may include reprimands, financial penalties, practising restrictions, suspension or exclusion from membership.

Disciplinary proceedings are separate from criminal prosecution.

A criminal acquittal does not automatically prevent professional disciplinary action, as the applicable rules and standards differ.

ACCA and Other Professional Bodies

ACCA, the Chartered Institute of Taxation and other professional organisations have their own reporting and disciplinary requirements.

The obligations depend on your membership, practising status and the circumstances of the investigation. If you belong to more than one professional body, you may need to consider the requirements of each.

Do not assume that an obligation under one body’s rules applies identically to another.

Fit and Proper Requirements for Tax Agents

HMRC also has powers and procedures relating to tax agents who fail to meet applicable standards. Serious concerns about an agent’s involvement in tax fraud may affect their ability to act for clients.

However, an investigation does not automatically result in removal of agent access or professional authorisation.

The consequences depend on the relevant legal powers and findings.

What Are the Penalties if I Am Convicted?

The potential sentence depends on the offence charged, the amount involved and your role.

A person who knowingly helped organise a substantial VAT fraud may face different consequences from someone whose involvement was limited.

The Value Added Tax Act 1994

Fraudulent evasion of VAT carries a maximum sentence of fourteen years‘ imprisonment in the Crown Court for offences committed on or after 22 February 2024.

For offences committed before that date, the previous maximum of seven years applies. An unlimited fine may also be imposed. The court considers the value of the fraud, the defendant’s involvement, planning and other aggravating or mitigating circumstances.

A professional’s position of trust may be relevant where the evidence establishes that the role was abused to facilitate offending.

Conspiracy to Defraud

Conspiracy to defraud carries a maximum sentence of ten years’ imprisonment. It concerns a dishonest agreement rather than simply the preparation of an incorrect return.

The prosecution must establish your involvement in that agreement. If convicted, the sentence will reflect the seriousness of the offending and your role in the scheme.

Confiscation and Civil Recovery

A conviction may lead to confiscation proceedings under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. The court can assess the financial benefit obtained from criminal conduct and determine the amount recoverable.

Professional fees received in connection with fraudulent conduct may be relevant to that assessment, depending on the circumstances. Civil recovery of property connected with unlawful conduct may also be possible without a criminal conviction where the statutory requirements are satisfied.

Financial Penalties Outside the Criminal Process

Civil tax penalties may arise separately from criminal proceedings. For example, HMRC can impose penalties for certain inaccurate returns where the relevant statutory conditions are met.

However, the rules governing penalties imposed on taxpayers differ from those that may apply to agents who deliberately enable inaccuracies.

An accountant is not automatically liable for a client’s VAT penalties merely because they prepared the return. Any personal penalty must have its own legal basis.

How Should I Preserve Working Papers and Records?

Preserve all records connected with the clients and VAT returns under investigation.

These documents may help establish what instructions you received, what checks you carried out and what you understood when submitting the returns.

What to Preserve and Why

Keep engagement letters, client instructions, invoices, working papers, VAT calculations, correspondence and filing confirmations. Records of questions you raised with clients and their responses may be particularly relevant.

They can help explain whether you relied on information supplied in the ordinary course of your work or knowingly participated in a fraudulent arrangement. Do not delete, alter or recreate documents after becoming aware of an investigation.

How to Store Records Securely

Preserve original electronic files, including relevant emails and any available metadata. Ensure that records held in accounting software or practice management systems are not lost through automatic deletion or account closure.

Keep the files secure and maintain appropriate access controls. Where records belong to clients, consider your confidentiality obligations before making copies or transferring them outside authorised systems.

Your solicitor can advise which documents HMRC is entitled to request, whether any statutory exemptions apply and how to respond lawfully.

Legal professional privilege may protect your communications with the solicitor, but it does not automatically protect records created before legal advice was sought.

The purpose is to preserve the evidence and comply with valid obligations without making unnecessary disclosures.

Practical Support for Accountants Under HMRC MTIC Investigation

If HMRC has contacted you about VAT returns filed for clients now facing MTIC fraud charges, a solicitor can help establish whether you are being approached as a witness or investigated as a suspect.

They can review your working papers, assess the evidence concerning your knowledge of the transactions and advise on any interview under caution. Independent legal advice may also help you address confidentiality, anti-money laundering obligations and professional reporting requirements.

Ashmans Solicitors advises accountants, tax advisers and other professionals facing fraud and financial crime investigations.

Speak to our fraud and financial crime team for advice about your position.

You can also send an online enquiry.


Search our legal articles

Free expert guidance on criminal law, your rights, and what to expect at every stage.

Searching Legal Help Hub articles